As we enter 2025, I’ve spent over 6 months using the iPhone 15 Pro Max, and with the launch of the Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra, it’s time to break down the real differences and ultimately determine which phone is better.
In this article, we’ll dive deep into comparisons on various aspects such as display, AI features, S Pen, operating systems, and camera quality.
This analysis will provide a thorough look at both devices to help you make an informed decision.
Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra Advantages
Superior Display with Durability
One of the standout features of the Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra is its display. While the S24 Ultra peaks at 1600 nits of brightness—slightly lower than the 2000 nits on the iPhone 15 Pro Max—what really stands out is the durability of its screen.
With Corning’s Gorilla Glass Armor, the S24 Ultra is four times more scratch-resistant and three times better at surviving drops.
This makes it a much tougher device compared to the iPhone, especially for users who tend to be rough on their phones.
Galaxy AI: Smarter and More Useful Features
Samsung has implemented several innovative AI features with the S24 Ultra, like Circle Search, where you can simply circle anything on the screen and search for it in Google.
Additionally, Generative Edit allows for advanced photo editing, similar to Google’s Magic Editor, enabling users to remove or move objects within a photo.
While Apple’s processing power is arguably superior, Samsung’s incorporation of AI into its device is more advanced in terms of user interaction and versatility.
S Pen and One UI Customization
The S Pen continues to be one of the most unique features of the Ultra series, offering an entirely new way to interact with your phone. You can write notes, draw, and even control the camera remotely with the S Pen.
Moreover, Samsung’s One UI, based on Android, is highly customizable. Whether it’s split multitasking, the Edge Panel to keep your favorite apps handy, or the ability to tweak the user interface through Samsung’s Good Lock app, the level of personalization is far greater than what’s available with iOS.
iPhone 15 Pro Max Advantages
Seamless Apple Ecosystem Integration
If you value ecosystem integration, the iPhone 15 Pro Max has a clear advantage. Apple’s ecosystem—spanning devices like the Mac, iPad, and Apple Watch—works seamlessly together.
Features like Handoff make it effortless to continue tasks across devices, such as drafting an email on the iPhone and finishing it on your Mac.
In contrast, Samsung relies on partnerships with Google and Microsoft, which adds some friction in syncing across devices and requires additional apps and configurations to match the ease of Apple’s integration.
Unmatched Video Quality
When it comes to video quality, the iPhone 15 Pro Max shines. With the new support for ProRes Log, the iPhone enables superior video recording and greater flexibility in post-production color grading.
Additionally, the smoother zooming transitions between camera lenses during video recording make the iPhone an excellent choice for videographers.
These features are particularly appealing for those who want the best video recording experience.
iOS Consistency and Aesthetic Excellence
iOS on the iPhone 15 Pro Max offers a consistent, aesthetically pleasing experience. Apple’s built-in apps like the Weather app stand out with their beautiful design, and iOS widgets are more consistent and visually cohesive compared to the customization options on Android.
Plus, features like Dynamic Island on the iPhone—showing ongoing information like timers or sports scores—are better thought out and implemented than similar features on the Galaxy S24 Ultra.
Camera Systems: A Deep Dive
Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra Camera Performance
The Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra delivers vibrant, warm colors and deep saturation, particularly in sky shots and distant objects. The images tend to be sharper as well, thanks to its advanced sensor technology.
However, there’s a minor issue with video recording, where it occasionally starts with a brief black screen, which can be bothersome for users.
On the plus side, the S24 Ultra excels in low-light selfies, producing clearer images in dim environments.
iPhone 15 Pro Max Camera Edge
Galaxy S24 vs iPhone 15 comparisonWhile the S24 Ultra excels in certain areas, the iPhone 15 Pro Max remains superior in overall image quality. Thanks to a lower aperture, the iPhone produces better depth of field, resulting in photos with a more professional look.
In terms of video, the iPhone takes the lead, particularly with ProRes Log support, offering more flexibility and control during editing.
The iPhone’s smoother zoom transitions during video recording further enhance its appeal for content creators.
Conclusion: Which Phone is the Best for You?
When evaluating hardware and software, the Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra offers notable advantages in areas like display quality, durability, and AI features.
However, when it comes to the ecosystem and seamless integration across devices, the iPhone 15 Pro Max stands out. If flexibility and cutting-edge features are your priority, the S24 Ultra is a clear winner.
But if you value a more integrated, smooth user experience with reliable video capabilities, the iPhone 15 Pro Max is the better choice.
Ultimately, the best phone for you will depend on your personal preferences—whether you prioritize flexibility and innovation or prefer the seamless integration and consistency offered by Apple’s ecosystem.
